TRADEMARK2U · Intellectual Property · Kuala Lumpur

Copyright resources

Chapter 10 — Remedies and the Assessment of Damages

Five focused articles on remedies and the assessment of damages.

Creative professionals reviewing original artwork and working drafts — copyright damages

Copyright damages: explore five articles on Choose the Monetary Remedy That Matches the Claim, Statutory Damages Are Capped Awards Rather than Fixed Tariffs, A Software Quotation Can Help Value a Lost Opportunity. Use the contents below to jump to a topic, and follow the related guides to continue your reading.

Adapted from a manuscript by Lawrence Yip.

General information, not legal advice. These articles reflect the supplied editorial collection and its citation register; check current law and the original authorities before relying on them.

10.1

Choose the Monetary Remedy That Matches the Claim

Compensatory damages, an account of profits and statutory damages address different remedial questions. Section 37 of the Copyright Act 1987 provides these forms of relief subject to its election and combination rules. They are not an unrestricted cumulative entitlement.[55]

Compensatory damages focus on the claimant's loss. An account of profits instead concerns the defendant's attributable gains. Statutory damages provide a separate route governed by statutory limits and considerations. The evidence required for one measure may not establish another.

A claimant who lost a licensing opportunity should preserve the relevant negotiations, pricing and exploitation period. A claimant seeking an account needs evidence supporting the identification of profits attributable to the infringement. Gross receipts alone may not answer the necessary calculation.

The choice should be considered before the assessment stage. Pleadings, disclosure and the liability order should support the relief pursued. Selecting every monetary label without examining its legal basis can obscure the claim and produce an award vulnerable to challenge.

Sources and case references

  1. Copyright Act 1987 (Act 332), s 37(1)–(4).
10.2

Statutory Damages Are Capped Awards Rather than Fixed Tariffs

Section 37(1)(d) of the Copyright Act 1987 permits statutory damages of up to RM25,000 for each work, subject to an aggregate maximum of RM500,000. The relevant unit is the work, not every infringing copy. The statute treats the parts of a collective work as one work for this purpose.[56]

These figures are ceilings. They do not establish an automatic entitlement to the maximum whenever infringement is proved. The court considers factors including the nature and purpose of the infringing act, flagrancy, bad faith, loss or likely loss, benefit, the parties' conduct and deterrence.

The claimant must therefore identify the works and explain the factual basis for the amount sought. Counting separate files or uploads may not correctly identify the number of statutory works, particularly where the material forms a collective work.

Statutory damages can address difficulties associated with valuing loss, but they do not eliminate the need for evidence relevant to discretion. A carefully supported request explains both the statutory limit and why the circumstances justify the proposed award within it.

Sources and case references

  1. Copyright Act 1987 (Act 332), s 37(1)(d), (5), (8) and (10).
10.3

A Software Quotation Can Help Value a Lost Opportunity

Commercial documents prepared before litigation can assist the assessment of damages. In Altus Solutions Sdn Bhd v Rocket Integration Technology Sdn Bhd[57], the High Court considered quotations provided for patient-registry software services when valuing the loss associated with unauthorised use.

The quotations supplied a concrete commercial basis for the assessment. They were more informative than an unsupported figure devised after the dispute. Their scope and duration nevertheless had to be connected to the services and period established by the evidence.

The court did not treat proof of a defined period as proof of unlimited continuing exploitation. A claim for a longer period required further evidence. Where disclosure could substantiate that loss, the necessary material needed to be obtained before assessment.

Software businesses should preserve offers, correspondence and the assumptions underlying their prices. A package including hosting and maintenance may need explanation before its total price can support a copyright valuation. The arithmetic becomes meaningful only when the price and multiplier are attached to a proven commercial opportunity and period.

Sources and case references

  1. Altus Solutions Sdn Bhd v Rocket Integration Technology Sdn Bhd [2023] 4 CLJ 937 (High Court).
10.4

Read a Damages Award with the Order That Authorised It

A reported monetary result cannot safely be treated as a tariff for later cases. In Altus Solutions Sdn Bhd v Rocket Integration Technology Sdn Bhd[58], the assessment produced compensatory, statutory and additional awards in the context of an earlier unappealed judgment and the parties' positions at assessment.

That procedural setting is essential. The decision does not establish a general right to accumulate every monetary remedy despite the election provisions in section 37 of the Copyright Act 1987. The liability order and the issues still open for determination must be read before relying on the amount awarded.[59]

The same discipline applies when comparing cases. A principal award, interest and costs serve different purposes. Combining them into one headline can conceal how the substantive compensation was calculated and which further sums resulted from the proceedings.

When advising on quantum, identify the head of relief, its statutory basis and the evidence supporting it. A larger award in another case is useful only if its legal and factual basis is comparable. The number alone cannot determine the value of a different infringement.

Sources and case references

  1. Altus Solutions Sdn Bhd v Rocket Integration Technology Sdn Bhd [2023] 4 CLJ 937 (High Court).
  2. Copyright Act 1987 (Act 332), s 37(1)–(4), (7)–(9).
10.5

An Injunction Should Describe the Conduct to Be Restrained

An injunction can address continuing or threatened infringement, but its terms should correspond to the established right and conduct. Section 37 of the Copyright Act 1987 empowers the court to grant injunctive relief alongside other appropriate remedies.[60]

A request to restrain all competition is different from a request to restrain reproduction of identified artwork. The order should allow the defendant to understand which work and acts are covered. Where only one component of a catalogue infringes, a demand extending to unrelated material needs its own justification.

Practical implementation also matters. Online material may appear across several accounts or versions, and manufactured stock may incorporate the work in different products. Identifying those locations and forms helps the court formulate effective relief without relying on vague descriptions.

The claimant should prepare the proposed restraint together with the evidential comparison. A clearly defined order supports compliance and reduces later argument over revised material. Monetary compensation for past conduct and restraint of future conduct should each be connected to the purpose they are intended to serve.

Sources and case references

  1. Copyright Act 1987 (Act 332), s 37(1)(a), (e).
WhatsApp us