Music and broadcast copyright: explore five articles on A Music Track Contains More than One Legal Interest, A Royalty Demand Must Explain the Authority to Collect, Performers Remuneration Requires the Correct Legal Route. Use the contents below to jump to a topic, and follow the related guides to continue your reading.
Adapted from a manuscript by Lawrence Yip.
General information, not legal advice. These articles reflect the supplied editorial collection and its citation register; check current law and the original authorities before relying on them.
A Music Track Contains More than One Legal Interest
A recorded song can involve copyright in lyrics, a musical composition and a sound recording, together with performers' rights. These interests arise under different provisions and may belong to different persons.[50]
Permission relating to one layer should not be assumed to clear the others. A venue proposing to play recorded music publicly needs to identify the rights engaged by that use. A producer incorporating an existing recording into a video faces a different clearance exercise from commissioning an entirely new recording.
The finished track's apparent unity can hide this legal structure. Buying a file or subscribing to a service gives access under the relevant arrangement; it does not automatically establish permission for every public or commercial exploitation.
An effective clearance record identifies the proposed act and the authority granting permission for each relevant interest. It should also distinguish ownership, representation and collection authority. This prevents a payment described generally as a music royalty from being treated as proof that every necessary right has been obtained.
Sources and case references
- Copyright Act 1987 (Act 332), ss 3, 7, 13 and 16A–16B.
A Royalty Demand Must Explain the Authority to Collect
A demand for music-related payment should identify both the right and the claimant's authority. The Copyright Act 1987 distinguishes copyright licensing and collective administration from performers' equitable remuneration. Those statutory routes should not be collapsed into a single general entitlement to royalties.[51]
An organisation may own relevant rights, administer them under a mandate or rely on a particular statutory role. The documents should establish which capacity applies and whether it covers the repertoire, use and period in dispute. An invoice records a demand; it does not by itself prove the underlying entitlement.
Users should compare the proposed licence with what actually occurs at their premises or through their service. A permission for one category of use may leave another outside its terms. Where several bodies approach the same business, the inquiry should determine whether they represent separate rights or overlapping demands.
Clear documentation benefits both sides. It allows the right holder to explain the charge and the user to assess the permission received, without assuming either that every demand is valid or that one payment resolves every musical interest.
Sources and case references
- Copyright Act 1987 (Act 332), ss 16B, 27 and 27A–27L.
Performers Remuneration Requires the Correct Legal Route
In Prism Bhd v Measat Broadcast Network System Sdn Bhd[52], the High Court distinguished copyright licence fees from performers' equitable remuneration. The collecting body's status and agreements with performers did not establish the payment claim as pleaded against the broadcaster.
For the use in issue, section 16B supplied the relevant remuneration framework. There was no agreement with the broadcaster fixing the amount and no Copyright Tribunal determination on which the asserted claim could properly proceed. The court struck out the action, while preserving the performers' ability to pursue the statutory process.
The decision also illustrates why a representation mandate must be distinguished from an assignment of a payment right. Authority to act for performers does not necessarily establish entitlement to sue in the intermediary's own name for the particular sum demanded.
The case used the legislation and licensing-body terminology applicable at the time. Its practical lesson remains to identify the precise right, the method of fixing payment and the claimant's standing. A commercially familiar label such as royalty cannot supply a missing statutory or contractual basis.
Sources and case references
- Prism Bhd v Measat Broadcast Network System Sdn Bhd [2017] 9 MLJ 557 (High Court).
A Restaurant Screening Requires Permission for Its Audience
In The Football Association Premier League Ltd & Anor v Bar Theory Sdn Bhd & Ors[53], the High Court considered unauthorised public screening of Premier League coverage in a restaurant bar. The claim identified film and artistic works within the coverage, rather than asserting copyright in football as an abstract sporting event.
The establishment actively supplied access through its equipment to patrons. The court held that the conduct engaged communication to the public and public showing under the Copyright Act 1987. Technical access to a feed did not establish permission for the commercial screening.
The remedy must also be stated accurately. The parties narrowed the proceedings to a declaration, relinquishing the other prayers. The reported disposition therefore should not be described as a damages award or an injunction that was never granted.
Venues should check whether their subscription or other permission covers the intended premises, audience and activity. A private viewing arrangement does not automatically resolve a separately promoted public event. Retaining the relevant commercial permission is more reliable than assuming that a functioning decoder authorises whatever can be displayed.
Sources and case references
- The Football Association Premier League Ltd & Anor v Bar Theory Sdn Bhd & Ors [2023] 1 CLJ 471 (High Court).
Online Circulation Does Not Authorise Advertising Reuse
In Sara Nadzirah bt Zulkifli v Khirulanuar bin Mohamadiah (t/a Ezydurian Services)[54], the High Court considered a short Instagram video reposted on a durian business's Facebook account without consent. The defendant's explanations included the video's circulation through WhatsApp and an asserted absence of harmful intention.
The court recognised the video as a protected film and allowed summary judgment on infringement. Circulation online did not supply a licence, and the exceptions invoked did not fit the actual reuse. A disclaimer or apology was not a substitute for permission.
The case separately addressed an earlier ex parte injunction that had lapsed. The claimant's success on infringement did not cure the procedural deficiencies in the application concerning that order. Damages remained for assessment rather than being fixed in the reported decision.
Businesses should obtain permission that describes the intended platform and advertising use before reposting a creator's video. Claimants should preserve the post and its context while observing the timetable for any interim application. Sound substantive rights and valid procedural steps are both necessary to obtain the particular relief sought.
Sources and case references
- Sara Nadzirah bt Zulkifli v Khirulanuar bin Mohamadiah (t/a Ezydurian Services) [2023] MLJU 267 (High Court).

